Rent Stabilization in Staten Island

Want to skip straight to checking your own building? Use the RentCheckMe address checker.

Overview of Rent Stabilization in Staten Island

Staten Island is home to roughly 500,000 residents and is the most suburban of New York City's five boroughs. With approximately 35% of its households renting — compared to over 75% in the Bronx or Manhattan — Staten Island has the lowest renter share in the city. That suburban character is reflected in its housing stock: large swaths of the borough consist of single-family and two-family homes, co-ops, and condominiums that are entirely outside the rent stabilization system. As a result, Staten Island's stabilized housing inventory is proportionally far smaller than those of Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, or Manhattan.

Nevertheless, rent stabilization has real significance for Staten Island tenants who do live in eligible buildings. Mid-century apartment complexes in neighborhoods such as St. George, Stapleton, New Brighton, and Port Richmond — areas that developed substantial multi-family housing stock in the postwar decades — are home to buildings that fall squarely within the stabilization framework. The borough's relative affordability compared to Manhattan has historically made it attractive to working-class and middle-income families, many of whom depend on stabilization's rent caps and eviction protections to remain housed.

Rent stabilization on Staten Island is governed by the NYC Rent Stabilization Law of 1969 and the Emergency Tenant Protection Act of 1974, and is administered statewide by NYS Homes and Community Renewal (HCR) through its Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR). The landmark Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act (HSTPA) of 2019 strengthened these rules significantly — eliminating vacancy decontrol and curtailing landlords' ability to remove apartments from stabilization — giving Staten Island tenants in covered buildings some of the strongest tenant protections in the country.

Who Is Covered?

Rent stabilization coverage in Staten Island follows the same criteria applied citywide. Whether a unit is covered depends primarily on the age of the building, the number of units, and whether the owner has received certain tax benefits. The following factors determine eligibility:

• Post-1947, pre-1974 construction with 6+ units: Residential buildings on Staten Island with six or more units constructed after February 1, 1947, and before January 1, 1974, are generally subject to rent stabilization.
• J-51 tax benefits: Buildings of any age that received J-51 tax abatements for renovation or rehabilitation are required to stabilize their units for the duration of the benefit period. Some Staten Island apartment buildings modernized under J-51 fall into this category even if they would otherwise be exempt.
• 421-a tax benefits: Newer construction that received 421-a tax exemptions — a program designed to incentivize residential development — must maintain rent stabilization during the benefit period. A limited number of Staten Island developments qualify.
• Pre-February 1, 1947 buildings: Older buildings with qualifying tenants may instead be subject to rent control (the Maximum Base Rent system), a shrinking and separate category. If a rent-controlled apartment becomes vacant, it typically becomes rent stabilized rather than decontrolled.
• Voluntary entry: Landlords of smaller buildings occasionally enter the stabilization system voluntarily, often in exchange for financing or tax benefits.

The following are not covered by rent stabilization:

• Buildings constructed after January 1, 1974, that did not receive J-51 or 421-a tax benefits
• Single-family homes and owner-occupied one- or two-family houses
• Condominiums and co-operatives (the unit owner is not a stabilized tenant)
• Buildings with five or fewer units that have not entered stabilization voluntarily or through a tax-benefit program
• Units where the legal regulated rent has been permanently deregulated — though post-HSTPA 2019, deregulation is far more limited than it was before
• Hotels, transient lodging, and certain other non-standard residential arrangements

Rent Increase Limits

Rent increases for stabilized apartments in Staten Island are set each year by the New York City Rent Guidelines Board (RGB), an appointed body that reviews operating costs, vacancy rates, and economic conditions before voting on allowable increases. The RGB's approved increases apply to lease renewals citywide — including Staten Island — that commence on or after October 1 of the applicable year.

For leases commencing October 1, 2024 through September 30, 2025, the allowable increases are:

• 1-year lease renewal: 2.75%
• 2-year lease renewal: 5.25%

These percentages are applied to the tenant's current legal regulated rent — not necessarily what the tenant actually pays if there is a preferential rent arrangement. Under changes made by HSTPA 2019, landlords who charged a preferential rent (an amount below the legal regulated rent) are now significantly restricted in their ability to suddenly restore the full legal rent at renewal; in most cases the preferential rent becomes the base for calculating increases going forward. Tenants who believe their landlord is attempting an improper preferential rent restoration should contact DHCR promptly.

Landlords must offer a lease renewal in writing between 90 and 150 days before the existing lease expires. The renewal offer must be at the RGB-approved rate — no more, no less. A landlord cannot condition renewal on the tenant accepting a higher increase, nor can they refuse to renew without a legally recognized reason. Individual Apartment Improvement (IAI) increases, which historically allowed landlords to raise rents substantially after renovating a vacant unit, are now capped at $15,000 in improvements over 15 years under HSTPA 2019, limiting their impact.

Your Rights as a Rent Stabilized Tenant

If you live in a rent-stabilized apartment on Staten Island, you have a defined set of legal rights that landlords are prohibited from overriding by contract or informal pressure:

• Right to lease renewal: Your landlord must offer you a renewal lease at the RGB-approved rate. Failure to do so is a violation you can report to DHCR.
• Just cause eviction protection: A landlord cannot remove you without a legally recognized reason. Grounds for eviction include nonpayment of rent, substantial lease violation, illegal subletting, owner or immediate family occupancy of the unit, and certain other DHCR-approved bases. A landlord who simply wants the unit back or dislikes a tenant cannot evict for that reason alone.
• Protection against harassment: Landlords are prohibited from harassing tenants to force them out of stabilized units. Harassment includes cutting off essential services (heat, hot water, elevator service), making threats, commencing frivolous legal proceedings, and other conduct designed to force a vacancy. Violations may be pursued under the NYC Administrative Code and Multiple Dwelling Law § 302-c.
• Right to essential services: Landlords must maintain all services they were providing when the lease was signed, including heat, hot water, and building common areas. A reduction in services without a corresponding rent reduction is a DHCR violation.
• Rent overcharge complaints: If your landlord charges more than the legal regulated rent, you can file an overcharge complaint with DHCR. Tenants who prevail may be entitled to a refund of the overcharge plus treble (triple) damages if the overcharge is found to be willful.
• Succession rights: Family members who have lived in a stabilized apartment as their primary residence for at least two years (one year for spouses and disabled or senior family members) may have the right to succeed to the tenancy if the named tenant vacates or dies.
• How to file a complaint: Complaints about overcharges, harassment, or service reductions can be filed online or by mail with DHCR at hcr.ny.gov. Tenants may also seek free legal assistance (see resources below).

How to Check If Your Apartment Is Rent Stabilized

Because Staten Island's stabilized stock is smaller and less uniformly distributed than in other boroughs, many tenants are unsure of their status. Follow these steps to find out:

1. Use RentCheckMe: Enter your address at rentcheckme.com for an instant check of whether your building appears in the rent-stabilized building registry. This is the fastest starting point.
2. Search the HCR Building Registry: Visit findmybuilding.hcr.ny.gov and enter your Staten Island address. HCR maintains the official list of buildings registered as rent-stabilized. Landlords of stabilized buildings are required to register annually with DHCR; a building's absence from the registry does not automatically mean it is unregulated, but registration is a strong indicator.
3. Check your lease rider: New York law requires landlords of stabilized units to attach a rent stabilization rider to every lease. The rider must state the current legal regulated rent, the previous tenant's rent, and the reason for any difference. If your lease lacks this rider, that itself may be a violation worth investigating.
4. Request your rent history from DHCR: You can request a free rent history for your apartment — showing registered rents going back years — through DHCR's online portal at hcr.ny.gov/am-i-rent-stabilized or by submitting a FOIL (Freedom of Information Law) request. This history can reveal whether your unit has been stabilized and whether your current rent matches the registered legal rent.
5. Contact HCR or a legal aid organization: If you are still uncertain after the above steps, call HCR's Tenant Helpline or reach out to a free legal services provider (see resources below). An attorney or housing counselor can review your lease documents and building history and advise you on your status and options.

Resources for Staten Island Tenants

• NYS Homes and Community Renewal (HCR) / DHCR — The state agency that administers rent stabilization and rent control statewide. File overcharge complaints, request rent histories, and access tenant guidance here.
• NYC Mayor's Office to Protect Tenants — City-level tenant resources, outreach programs, and guidance on navigating housing issues in all five boroughs including Staten Island.
• Legal Aid Society — Provides free civil legal services to low-income New Yorkers, including housing cases involving rent overcharges, eviction defense, and stabilization disputes.
• Housing Court Answers — Staffs help desks at NYC Housing Court locations and offers plain-language guidance on tenant rights, eviction procedures, and housing court navigation.
• Met Council on Housing — A citywide tenant membership organization offering advice, hotline counseling, and advocacy on rent stabilization and tenant protection issues.

Important: This article is a high-level overview and does not constitute legal advice. Laws and regulations change, and individual circumstances vary. For specific questions, contact NY HCR or a qualified attorney.

Frequently Asked Questions